Revert part of [9386d6f63468] because the new automatic function pointer binding cannot properly track per-context function mappings when the context is more complex than a single context-type pointer. e.g. it is fine for sqlite3_trace_v2() but it breaks down with sqlite3_create_collation() because that one needs to use the collation name as part of the context key and we cannot sensibly do so with the current code.

FossilOrigin-Name: 6cd21b79075367227b57bccf829cc7d4ccc7d7fbcfaed226b4c8e942ddae4eb6

ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-glue.js

@@ -141,7 +141,8 @@ self.sqlite3ApiBootstrap.initializers.push(function(sqlite3){
         "sqlite3*", "int", new wasm.xWrap.FuncPtrAdapter({
           name: 'xProgressHandler',
           signature: 'i(p)',
-          bindMode: 'singleton'
+          bindScope: 'context',
+          contextKey: (argIndex,argv)=>'sqlite3@'+argv[0]
         }), "*"
       ]
     ],
@@ -178,7 +179,12 @@ self.sqlite3ApiBootstrap.initializers.push(function(sqlite3){
      "sqlite3*", "string", "string", "string",
      "**", "**", "*", "*", "*"],
     ["sqlite3_total_changes", "int", "sqlite3*"],
-    ["sqlite3_trace_v2", "int", "sqlite3*", "int", "*", "*"],
+    ["sqlite3_trace_v2", "int", "sqlite3*", "int",
+     new wasm.xWrap.FuncPtrAdapter({
+       name: 'sqlite3_trace_v2::callback',
+       signature: 'i(ippp)',
+       contextKey: (argIndex, argv)=>'sqlite3@'+argv[0]
+     }), "*"],
     ["sqlite3_txn_state", "int", ["sqlite3*","string"]],
     /* Note that sqlite3_uri_...() have very specific requirements for
        their first C-string arguments, so we cannot perform any value
@@ -454,27 +460,44 @@ self.sqlite3ApiBootstrap.initializers.push(function(sqlite3){
 
   if(1){/* Bindings for sqlite3_create_collation() */
 
+    const __collationContextKey = (argIndex,argv)=>{
+      return 'argv['+argIndex+']:sqlite3@'+argv[0]+
+        ':'+((/*THIS IS WRONG. We can't sensibly use a converted-to-C-string
+                address here and don't have access to the JS string (IF ANY)
+                which the user passed in.*/
+          ''+argv[1]
+        ).toLowerCase());
+    };
     const __ccv2 = wasm.xWrap(
       'sqlite3_create_collation_v2', 'int',
-      'sqlite3*','string','int','*',
+      'sqlite3*','string','int','*','*','*'
+      /* int(*xCompare)(void*,int,const void*,int,const void*) */
+      /* void(*xDestroy(void*) */
+    );
+    if(0){
+      // Problem: we cannot, due to xWrap() arg-passing limitations,
+      // currently easily/efficiently get a per-collation distinct
+      // key for purposes of creating distinct FuncPtrAdapter contexts.
       new wasm.xWrap.FuncPtrAdapter({
         /* int(*xCompare)(void*,int,const void*,int,const void*) */
         name: 'xCompare',
         signature: 'i(pipip)',
-        bindMode: 'static'
+        bindScope: 'context',
+        contextKey: __collationContextKey
       }),
       new wasm.xWrap.FuncPtrAdapter({
         /* void(*xDestroy(void*) */
         name: 'xDestroy',
         signature: 'v(p)',
-        bindMode: 'static'
+        bindScope: 'context',
+        contextKey: __collationContextKey
       })
-    );
+    }
 
     /**
        Works exactly like C's sqlite3_create_collation_v2() except that:
 
-       1) It permits its two function arguments to be JS functions,
+       1) It accepts JS functions for its function-pointer arguments,
           for which it will install WASM-bound proxies. The bindings
           are "permanent," in that they will stay in the WASM environment
           until it shuts down unless the client somehow finds and removes
@@ -494,10 +517,19 @@ self.sqlite3ApiBootstrap.initializers.push(function(sqlite3){
           pDb, capi.SQLITE_FORMAT, "SQLITE_UTF8 is the only supported encoding."
         );
       }
-      let rc;
+      let rc, pfCompare, pfDestroy;
       try{
-        rc = __ccv2(pDb, zName, eTextRep, pArg, xCompare, xDestroy);
+        if(xCompare instanceof Function){
+          pfCompare = wasm.installFunction(xCompare, 'i(pipip)');
+        }
+        if(xDestroy instanceof Function){
+          pfDestroy = wasm.installFunction(xDestroy, 'v(p)');
+        }
+        rc = __ccv2(pDb, zName, eTextRep, pArg,
+                    pfCompare || xCompare, pfDestroy || xDestroy);
       }catch(e){
+        if(pfCompare) wasm.uninstallFunction(pfCompare);
+        if(pfDestroy) wasm.uninstallFunction(pfDestroy);
         rc = util.sqlite3_wasm_db_error(pDb, e);
       }
       return rc;
@@ -516,7 +548,7 @@ self.sqlite3ApiBootstrap.initializers.push(function(sqlite3){
                               ["sqlite3*", "string:flexible",
                                new wasm.xWrap.FuncPtrAdapter({
                                  signature: 'i(pipp)',
-                                 bindMode: 'transient'
+                                 bindScope: 'transient'
                                }), "*", "**"]);
     /* Documented in the api object's initializer. */
     capi.sqlite3_exec = function f(pDb, sql, callback, pVoid, pErrMsg){

ext/wasm/common/whwasmutil.js

@@ -1434,77 +1434,155 @@ self.WhWasmUtilInstaller = function(target){
     });
   }
 
-  const __FuncPtrBindModes = ['transient','static','singleton'];
   /**
-     EXPERIMENTAL.
+     EXPERIMENTAL! DO NOT USE IN CLIENT CODE!
 
      An attempt at adding function pointer conversion support to
      xWrap(). This type is recognized by xWrap() as a proxy for
-     converting a JS function to a C-side function, either permanently
+     converting a JS function to a C-side function, either
-     or only for the duration of a a single call into the C layer.
+     permanently, for the duration of a single call into the C layer,
+     or semi-contextual, where it may keep track of a single binding
+     for a given context and uninstall the binding if it's replaced.
+
+     Requires an options object with these properties:
+
+     - name (optional): string describing the function binding. This
+     is solely for debugging and error-reporting purposes. If not
+     provided, an empty string is assumed.
+
+     - signature: an function signature compatible with
+     jsFuncToWasm().
+
+     - bindScope (string): one of ('transient', 'context',
+       'singleton'). Bind scopes are:
+
+       - transient: it will convert JS functions to WASM only for the
+         duration of the xWrap()'d function call, using
+         scopedInstallFunction(). Before that call returns, the
+         WASM-side binding will be uninstalled.
+
+       - singleton: holds one function-pointer binding for this
+         instance. If it's called with a different function pointer,
+         it uninstalls the previous one after converting the new
+         value. This is only useful for use with "global" functions
+         which do not rely on any state other than this function
+         pointer. If the being-converted function pointer is intended
+         to be mapped to some sort of state object (e.g. an sqlite3*)
+         then "context" (see below) is the proper mode.
+
+       - context: similar to singleton mode but for a given "context",
+         where the context is a key provided by the user and possibly
+         dependent on a small amount of call-time context. This mode
+         is the default if bindScope is _not_ set but a property named
+         contextKey (described below) is.
+
+     FIXME: the contextKey definition is only useful for very basic
+     contexts and breaks down with dynamic ones like
+     sqlite3_create_collation().
+
+     - contextKey (function): only used if bindScope is not set or is
+       'context'. This function gets passed (argIndex,argv), where
+       argIndex is the index of this function pointer in its
+       _wrapping_ function's arguments and argv is the _current_
+       being-xWrap()-processed args array. All arguments to the left
+       of argIndex will have been processed by xWrap() by the time
+       this is called. argv[argIndex] will be the value the user
+       passed in to the xWrap()'d function for the argument this
+       FuncPtrAdapter is mapped to. Arguments to the right of
+       argv[argIndex] will not yet have been converted before this is
+       called. The function must return a key which uniquely
+       identifies this function mapping context for _this_
+       FuncPtrAdapter instance (other instances are not considered),
+       taking into account that C functions often take some sort of
+       state object as one or more of their arguments. As an example,
+       if the xWrap()'d function takes `(int,T*,functionPtr,X*)` and
+       this FuncPtrAdapter is the argv[2]nd arg, contextKey(2,argv)
+       might return 'T@'+argv[1], or even just argv[1].  Note,
+       however, that the (X*) argument will not yet have been
+       processed by the time this is called and should not be used as
+       part of that key. Similarly, C-string-type keys should not be
+       used as part of keys because they are normally transient in
+       this environment.
+
+     The constructor only saves the above state for later, and does
+     not actually bind any functions. Its convertArg() methor is
+     called via xWrap() to perform any bindings.
+
+     Caveats:
+
+     - singleton is globally singleton. This type does not currently
+     have enough context to apply, e.g., a different singleton for
+     each (sqlite3*) db handle.
   */
-  xArg.FuncPtrAdapter = class {
+  xArg.FuncPtrAdapter = function ctor(opt) {
-    /**
+    if(!(this instanceof xArg.FuncPtrAdapter)){
-       Requires an options object with these properties:
+      toss("FuncPtrAdapter can only be used as a constructor. Use 'new'.");
-
-       - signature: an function signature compatible with
-         jsFuncToWasm().
-
-       - bindMode (string): one of ('transient', 'static',
-         'singleton').  If 'transient', it uses
-         scopedInstallFunction() for its function bindings, meaning
-         they're limited to the lifetime of a single xWrap()-induced
-         function call. If it's 'static', the binding is permanent,
-         lasting the life of the WASM environment. If it's 'singleton'
-         then this function remembers the last function it installed
-         and uninstalls it before installing any replacements on
-         subsequent calls. If it's passed the exact same JS function
-         to install later, it will re-use the existing binding.
-
-       - name (optional): string describing the function binding. This
-         is solely for debugging and error-reporting purposes. If not
-         provided, an empty string is assumed.
-
-       The constructor only saves the above state for later, and does
-       not actually bind any functions. Its convertArg() methor is
-       called via xWrap() to perform any bindings.
-    */
-    constructor(opt){
-      this.signature = opt.signature;
-      if(__FuncPtrBindModes.indexOf(opt.bindMode)<0){
-        toss("Invalid options.bindMode ("+opt.bindMod+") for FuncPtrAdapter. "+
-             "Expecting one of: ("+__FuncPtrBindModes.join(', ')+')');
-      }
-      this.bindMode = opt.bindMode;
-      this.name = opt.name || '';
-      this.singleton = ('singleton'===this.bindMode) ? [] : undefined;
-      //console.warn("FuncPtrAdapter()",this.signature,this.transient);
     }
+    this.signature = opt.signature;
+    if(!opt.bindScope && (opt.contextKey instanceof Function)){
+      opt.bindScope = 'context';
+    }else if(ctor.bindScopes.indexOf(opt.bindScope)<0){
+      toss("Invalid options.bindScope ("+opt.bindMod+") for FuncPtrAdapter. "+
+           "Expecting one of: ("+ctor.bindScopes.join(', ')+')');
+    }
+    this.bindScope = opt.bindScope;
+    this.name = opt.name || '';
+    if(opt.contextKey) this.contextKey = opt.contextKey /*else inherit one*/;
+    this.isTransient = 'transient'===this.bindScope;
+    this.isContext = 'context'===this.bindScope;
+    if( ('singleton'===this.bindScope) ){
+      this.singleton = [];
+    }else{
+      this.singleton = undefined;
+    }
+    //console.warn("FuncPtrAdapter()",opt,this);
+  };
+  xArg.FuncPtrAdapter.bindScopes = [
+    'transient', 'context', 'singleton'
+  ];
+  xArg.FuncPtrAdapter.prototype = {
+    contextKey: function(argIndex,argv){
+      return this;
+    },
+    contextMap: function(key){
+      const cm = (this.__cmap || (this.__cmap = new Map));
+      let rc = cm.get(key);
+      if(undefined===rc) cm.set(key, (rc = []));
+      return rc;
+    },
     /**
        Gets called via xWrap() to "convert" v to a WASM-bound function
        pointer. If v is one of (a pointer, null, undefined) then
        (v||0) is returned, otherwise v must be a Function, for which
-       xit creates (if needed) a WASM function binding and returns the
+       it creates (if needed) a WASM function binding and returns the
-       WASM pointer to that binding. It throws if passed an invalid
+       WASM pointer to that binding. It will remember the binding for
-       type.
+       at least the next call, to avoid recreating the function
+       unnecessarily.
     */
-    convertArg(v){
+    convertArg: function(v,argIndex,argv){
       //console.warn("FuncPtrAdapter.convertArg()",this.signature,this.transient,v);
+      let pair = this.singleton;
+      if(!pair && this.isContext){
+        pair = this.contextMap(this.contextKey(argIndex, argv));
+      }
+      if(pair && pair[0]===v) return pair[1];
       if(v instanceof Function){
-        if(this.singleton && this.singleton[0]===v){
+        const fp = __installFunction(v, this.signature, this.isTransient);
-          return this.singleton[1];
+        if(pair){
-        }
+          if(pair[1]){
-        const fp = __installFunction(v, this.signature, 'transient'===this.bindMode);
+            try{target.uninstallFunction(pair[1])}
-        if(this.singleton){
-          if(this.singleton[1]){
-            try{target.uninstallFunction(this.singleton[1])}
             catch(e){/*ignored*/}
           }
-          this.singleton[0] = v;
+          pair[0] = v;
-          this.singleton[1] = fp;
+          pair[1] = fp;
         }
         return fp;
       }else if(target.isPtr(v) || null===v || undefined===v){
+        if(pair && pair[1]){
+          try{target.uninstallFunction(pair[1])}
+          catch(e){/*ignored*/}
+          pair[0] = pair[1] = (v || 0);
+        }
         return v || 0;
       }else{
         throw new TypeError("Invalid FuncPtrAdapter argument type. "+
@@ -1513,7 +1591,7 @@ self.WhWasmUtilInstaller = function(target){
                             this.signature+".");
       }
     }
-  };
+  }/*FuncPtrAdapter.prototype*/;
 
   const __xArgAdapterCheck =
         (t)=>xArg.get(t) || toss("Argument adapter not found:",t);
@@ -1521,7 +1599,7 @@ self.WhWasmUtilInstaller = function(target){
   const __xResultAdapterCheck =
         (t)=>xResult.get(t) || toss("Result adapter not found:",t);
 
-  cache.xWrap.convertArg = (t,v)=>__xArgAdapterCheck(t)(v);
+  cache.xWrap.convertArg = (t,...args)=>__xArgAdapterCheck(t)(...args);
   cache.xWrap.convertResult =
     (t,v)=>(null===t ? v : (t ? __xResultAdapterCheck(t)(v) : undefined));
 
@@ -1686,7 +1764,7 @@ self.WhWasmUtilInstaller = function(target){
     /*Verify the arg type conversions are valid...*/;
     if(undefined!==resultType && null!==resultType) __xResultAdapterCheck(resultType);
     for(const t of argTypes){
-      if(t instanceof xArg.FuncPtrAdapter) xArg.set(t, (v)=>t.convertArg(v));
+      if(t instanceof xArg.FuncPtrAdapter) xArg.set(t, (...args)=>t.convertArg(...args));
       else __xArgAdapterCheck(t);
     }
     const cxw = cache.xWrap;
@@ -1700,7 +1778,7 @@ self.WhWasmUtilInstaller = function(target){
       if(args.length!==xf.length) __argcMismatch(fname, xf.length);
       const scope = target.scopedAllocPush();
       try{
-        for(const i in args) args[i] = cxw.convertArg(argTypes[i], args[i]);
+        for(const i in args) args[i] = cxw.convertArg(argTypes[i], args[i], i, args);
         return cxw.convertResult(resultType, xf.apply(null,args));
       }finally{
         target.scopedAllocPop(scope);

ext/wasm/tester1.c-pp.js

@@ -1788,7 +1788,7 @@ self.sqlite3InitModule = sqlite3InitModule;
                   .assert(args[0] === 'testvtab')
                   .assert(args[1] === 'main')
                   .assert(args[2] === 'testvtab');
-                console.debug("xConnect() args =",args);
+                //console.debug("xConnect() args =",args);
                 const rc = capi.sqlite3_declare_vtab(
                   pDb, "CREATE TABLE ignored(a,b)"
                 );

manifest

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
-C Add\snew\slogging\scode\sSQLITE_NOTICE_RBU\sand\suse\sit\swhen\slogging\sfor\sthe\sspurious\serror\sthat\sRBU\sinjects\sinto\sSQLite\sas\spart\sof\sapplying\san\supdate.
+C Revert\spart\sof\s[9386d6f63468]\sbecause\sthe\snew\sautomatic\sfunction\spointer\sbinding\scannot\sproperly\strack\sper-context\sfunction\smappings\swhen\sthe\scontext\sis\smore\scomplex\sthan\sa\ssingle\scontext-type\spointer.\se.g.\sit\sis\sfine\sfor\ssqlite3_trace_v2()\sbut\sit\sbreaks\sdown\swith\ssqlite3_create_collation()\sbecause\sthat\sone\sneeds\sto\suse\sthe\scollation\sname\sas\spart\sof\sthe\scontext\skey\sand\swe\scannot\ssensibly\sdo\sso\swith\sthe\scurrent\scode.
-D 2022-12-12T17:33:36.415
+D 2022-12-12T18:42:39.215
 F .fossil-settings/empty-dirs dbb81e8fc0401ac46a1491ab34a7f2c7c0452f2f06b54ebb845d024ca8283ef1
 F .fossil-settings/ignore-glob 35175cdfcf539b2318cb04a9901442804be81cd677d8b889fcc9149c21f239ea
 F LICENSE.md df5091916dbb40e6e9686186587125e1b2ff51f022cc334e886c19a0e9982724
@@ -503,7 +503,7 @@ F ext/wasm/api/post-js-footer.js cd0a8ec768501d9bd45d325ab0442037fb0e33d1f3b4f08
 F ext/wasm/api/post-js-header.js 47b6b281f39ad59fa6e8b658308cd98ea292c286a68407b35ff3ed9cfd281a62
 F ext/wasm/api/pre-js.c-pp.js b88499dc303c21fc3f55f2c364a0f814f587b60a95784303881169f9e91c1d5f
 F ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-cleanup.js 680d5ccfff54459db136a49b2199d9f879c8405d9c99af1dda0cc5e7c29056f4
-F ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-glue.js 5c3854480b600195edd7a9c98a9ea4f07f59cc6abe7ab2f19d30cdaa62f24b78
+F ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-glue.js 1ff6deb11bd192c13cbd247e333a4739e2303aad3d1a9dc68defced2d7393375
 F ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-oo1.js 6d10849609231ccd46fa11b1d3fbbe0f45d9fe84c66a0b054601036540844300
 F ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-prologue.js 39fbca8f25219c218d631433828ede53be8d518aa9f0da480758a3ea8abc1be8
 F ext/wasm/api/sqlite3-api-worker1.js e94ba98e44afccfa482874cd9acb325883ade50ed1f9f9526beb9de1711f182f
@@ -521,7 +521,7 @@ F ext/wasm/c-pp.c 92285f7bce67ed7b7020b40fde8ed0982c442b63dc33df9dfd4b658d4a6c07
 F ext/wasm/common/SqliteTestUtil.js d8bf97ecb0705a2299765c8fc9e11b1a5ac7f10988bbf375a6558b7ca287067b
 F ext/wasm/common/emscripten.css 11bd104b6c0d597c67d40cc8ecc0a60dae2b965151e3b6a37fa5708bac3acd15
 F ext/wasm/common/testing.css 0ff15602a3ab2bad8aef2c3bd120c7ee3fd1c2054ad2ace7e214187ae68d926f
-F ext/wasm/common/whwasmutil.js 60531749126c3d505521b9e9a0adb468951e3a201ca65fdc8a37d20a6c1194e0
+F ext/wasm/common/whwasmutil.js 85bdcefc3ae4b550231da1f94b196e15458828d7652b1f61f86d20873ff915ed
 F ext/wasm/demo-123-worker.html a0b58d9caef098a626a1a1db567076fca4245e8d60ba94557ede8684350a81ed
 F ext/wasm/demo-123.html 8c70a412ce386bd3796534257935eb1e3ea5c581e5d5aea0490b8232e570a508
 F ext/wasm/demo-123.js ebae30756585bca655b4ab2553ec9236a87c23ad24fc8652115dcedb06d28df6
@@ -555,7 +555,7 @@ F ext/wasm/test-opfs-vfs.html 1f2d672f3f3fce810dfd48a8d56914aba22e45c6834e262555
 F ext/wasm/test-opfs-vfs.js 44363db07b2a20e73b0eb1808de4400ca71b703af718d0fa6d962f15e73bf2ac
 F ext/wasm/tester1-worker.html d43f3c131d88f10d00aff3e328fed13c858d674ea2ff1ff90225506137f85aa9
 F ext/wasm/tester1.c-pp.html d34bef3d48e5cbc1c7c06882ad240fec49bf88f5f65696cc2c72c416933aa406
-F ext/wasm/tester1.c-pp.js 6f7fcaeedff2c94fd9ebfd37a665cc7797524868b70fce2854ecab60b3d74274
+F ext/wasm/tester1.c-pp.js ee609a41cc1aabc971a6514b5d1b155f5f15d092ee015f5d03a204880532e62d
 F ext/wasm/tests/opfs/concurrency/index.html 86d8ac435074d1e7007b91105f4897f368c165e8cecb6a9aa3d81f5cf5dcbe70
 F ext/wasm/tests/opfs/concurrency/test.js a98016113eaf71e81ddbf71655aa29b0fed9a8b79a3cdd3620d1658eb1cc9a5d
 F ext/wasm/tests/opfs/concurrency/worker.js 0a8c1a3e6ebb38aabbee24f122693f1fb29d599948915c76906681bb7da1d3d2
@@ -2067,8 +2067,8 @@ F vsixtest/vsixtest.tcl 6a9a6ab600c25a91a7acc6293828957a386a8a93
 F vsixtest/vsixtest.vcxproj.data 2ed517e100c66dc455b492e1a33350c1b20fbcdc
 F vsixtest/vsixtest.vcxproj.filters 37e51ffedcdb064aad6ff33b6148725226cd608e
 F vsixtest/vsixtest_TemporaryKey.pfx e5b1b036facdb453873e7084e1cae9102ccc67a0
-P 9386d6f634680b4e0fa5487c34c63acb29f0b7a6ae738b8f6164ad084a229b62
+P cd881d35150be7f28cc1ca1eca0e950b5a039bef61190fcae4f944ef0e91f234
-R 11d1a6998924a37a55370025a25b1ff2
+R 27f9155fc78c491f877b292e106a06a7
-U dan
+U stephan
-Z 8aa12dbc9239c3322fc6c9c4ad75ec00
+Z cb8c8da215323ce40b195861e9820bf0
 # Remove this line to create a well-formed Fossil manifest.

manifest.uuid

@@ -1 +1 @@
-cd881d35150be7f28cc1ca1eca0e950b5a039bef61190fcae4f944ef0e91f234
+6cd21b79075367227b57bccf829cc7d4ccc7d7fbcfaed226b4c8e942ddae4eb6