Fix:
===
Backport Bug#11756194 to mysql-5.5. slave breaks if
'drop database' fails on master and mismatched tables on
slave.
'DROP TABLE <deleted tables>' was binlogged when
'DROP DATABASE' failed and at least one table was deleted
from the database. The log event would lead slave SQL thread
stop if some of the tables did not exist on slave.
After this patch, It is always binlogged with 'IF EXISTS'
option.
The test case makes use of the fine DEBUG_SYNC facility. Furthermore,
since it needs synchronization on internal threads (dump and SQL
threads) the server code has DEBUG_SYNC commands internally deployed
and activated through the DBUG_EXECUTE_IF macro. The internal
DBUG_SYNC commands are then controlled from the test case through the
DEBUG variable.
There were three problems around the DEBUG + DEBUG_SYNC facility
usage:
1. When signaling the SQL thread to continue, the test would reset
immediately the DEBUG_SYNC variable. This could mean that the SQL
thread might loose the signal and continue to wait forever;
2. A similar scenario was happening with the dump thread on the
master. This thread was instructed to wait, and later it would be
signaled to continue, but immediately after the DEBUG_SYNC would be
reset. This could lead to the dump thread missing the signal and
wait forever;
3. The test was not cleaning itself up with respect to the
instrumentation of the dump thread. This would leave the
conditional execution of an internal DEBUG_SYNC command active
(through the usage of DBUG_EXECUTE_IF).
We fix#1 and #2 by waiting for the threads to receive the signal and
only then issue the reset. We fix#3 by reseting the DEBUG variable,
thus deactivating the dump thread internal DEBUG_SYNC command.
DURING INNODB RECOVERY
Problem:
=======
The connection 'master' is dropped by mysqltest after
rpl_end.inc. At this point, dropping temporary tables
at the connection 'master' are not synced at slave.
So, the temporary tables replicated from master remain
on slave leading to an inconsistent close of the test.
The following test thus complains about the presence of
temporary table(s) left over from the previous test.
Fix:
===
- Put explicit drop commands in replication tests so
that the temporary tables are dropped at slave as well.
- Added the check for Slave_open_temp_tables in
mtr_check.sql to warn about the remaining temporary
table, if any, at the close of a test.
main.mysqlbinlog_row_innodb are skipped by mtr
=== Problem ===
The following tests are wrongly placed in main suite and as a
result these are not run with proper binlog format combinations.
Some are always skipped by mtr.
1) mysqlbinlog_row_myisam
2) mysqlbinlog_row_innodb
3) mysqlbinlog_row.test
4) mysqlbinlog_row_trans.test
5) mysqlbinlog-cp932
6) mysqlbinlog2
7) mysqlbinlog_base64
=== Background ===
mtr runs the tests placed in main suite with binlog format=stmt.
Those that need to be tested against binlog format=row or mixed
or more than one binlog format and require only one mysql server
are placed in binlog suite. mtr runs tests in binlog suite with
all three binlog formats(stmt,row and mixed).
=== Fix ===
1) Moved the test listed in problem section above to binlog suite.
2) Added prefix "binlog_" to the name of each test case moved.
Renamed the coresponding result files and option files accordingly.
PROBLEM:
--------
When binary log statements are replayed on the slave, BEGIN is represented
in com_counters but COMMIT is not. Similarly in 'ROW' based replication
'INSERT','UPDATE',and 'DELETE' com_counters are not getting incremented
when the binary log statements are replayed at slave.
ANALYSIS:
---------
In 'ROW' based replication for COMMIT,INSERT,UPDATE and DELETE operations
following special events are invoked.
Xid_log_event,Write_rows_log_event,Update_rows_log_event,Update_rows_log_event.
The above mentioned events doesn't go through the parser where the
'COM_COUNTERS' are incremented.
FIX:
-----
Increment statements are added at appropriate events.
Respective functions are listed below.
'Xid_log_event::do_apply_event'
'Write_rows_log_event::do_before_row_operations'
'Update_rows_log_event::do_before_row_operations'
'Delete_rows_log_event::do_before_row_operations'
Problem: Statements that write to tables with auto_increment columns
based on the selection from another table, may lead to master
and slave going out of sync, as the order in which the rows
are retrieved from the table may differ on master and slave.
Solution: We mark writing to a table with auto_increment table
based on the rows selected from another table as unsafe. This
will cause the execution of such statements to throw a warning
and forces the statement to be logged in ROW if the logging
format is mixed.
Changes:
1. All the statements that writes to a table with auto_increment
column(s) based on the rows fetched from another table, will now
be unsafe.
2. CREATE TABLE with SELECT will now be unsafe.
Problem: Statements that write to tables with auto_increment columns
based on the selection from another table, may lead to master
and slave going out of sync, as the order in which the rows
are retrived from the table may differ on master and slave.
Solution: We mark writing to a table with auto_increment table
as unsafe. This will cause the execution of such statements to
throw a warning and forces the statement to be logged in ROW if
the logging format is mixed.
Changes:
1. All the statements that writes to a table with auto_increment
column(s) based on the rows fetched from another table, will now
be unsafe.
2. CREATE TABLE with SELECT will now be unsafe.
If an error message contains '\' backslash it is displayed correctly
through show-slave-status or
query_get_value(SHOW SLAVE STATUS, Last_IO_Error, 1);. But when
SELECT REPLACE(...) is applied backslash is escaped resulting in a
different test output.
Disabled backslash escape on show_slave_status.inc and replaced '\' for
'/' using replace_regex function in order to achieve the same test
output when different path separators are used.
The server crashes when receiving a COM_BINLOG_DUMP command with a position of 0 or
larger than the file size.
The execution proceeds to an error block having the last read replication coordinates
pointer be NULL and its dereferencing crashed the server.
Fixed with making "public" previously used only for heartbeat coordinates.
Test extra/rpl_tests/rpl_extra_col_master.test (used by
rpl_extra_col_master_*) ends with the active connection pointing to the
slave. Thus, the two last tests never succeed in changing the binlog
format of the master away from 'row'. With correct active connection
(master) tests fail for binlog 'statement' and 'mixed' formats.
Tests rpl_extra_col_master_* only run when binary log format is
row. Statement and mix replication do not make sense in this
tests since it will try to execute statements on columns that do
not exist. This fix is basically a backport from mysql-5.5, see
changes done as part of BUG 39934.
Problem: The following statements can cause the slave to go out of sync
if logged in statement format:
INSERT IGNORE...SELECT
INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE
REPLACE ... SELECT
UPDATE IGNORE :
CREATE ... IGNORE SELECT
CREATE ... REPLACE SELECT
Background: Since the order of the rows returned by the SELECT
statement or otherwise may differ on master and slave, therefore
the above statements may cuase the salve to go out of sync with
the master.
Fix:
Issue a warning when statements like the above are exectued and
the bin-logging format is statement. If the logging format is mixed,
use row based logging. Marking a statement as unsafe has been
done in the sql/sql_parse.cc instead of sql/sql_yacc.cc, because while
parsing for a token has been done we cannot be sure if the parsing
of the other tokens has been done as well.
Six new warning messages has been added for each unsafe statement.
binlog.binlog_unsafe.test has been updated to incoporate these additional unsafe statments.
******
BUG#11758262 - 50439: MARK INSERT...SEL...ON DUP KEY UPD,REPLACE...SEL,CREATE...[IGN|REPL] SEL
Problem: The following statements can cause the slave to go out of sync
if logged in statement format:
INSERT IGNORE...SELECT
INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE
REPLACE ... SELECT
UPDATE IGNORE :
CREATE ... IGNORE SELECT
CREATE ... REPLACE SELECT
Background: Since the order of the rows returned by the SELECT
statement or otherwise may differ on master and slave, therefore
the above statements may cuase the salve to go out of sync with
the master.
Fix:
Issue a warning when statements like the above are exectued and
the bin-logging format is statement. If the logging format is mixed,
use row based logging. Marking a statement as unsafe has been
done in the sql/sql_parse.cc instead of sql/sql_yacc.cc, because while
parsing for a token has been done we cannot be sure if the parsing
of the other tokens has been done as well.
Six new warning messages has been added for each unsafe statement.
binlog.binlog_unsafe.test has been updated to incoporate these additional unsafe statments.
Before BUG#28796, an empty host was used to identify that an instance was no
longer a slave. However, BUG#28796 changed this behavior and one cannot set
an empty host. Besides, a RESET SLAVE only cleans up information on the next
event to retrieve from the master, disables ssl and resets heartbeat period.
So a call to SHOW SLAVE STATUS after issuing a RESET SLAVE still returns some
valid information, such as host, port, user and password.
To fix this problem, we have introduced the command RESET SLAVE ALL that does
what a regular RESET SLAVE does and also clears host, port, user and password
information thus allowing users to identify when an instance is no longer a
slave.
- add support for choosing the engine of test
table(t1) with $engine_type
- add primary key to the test table(t1) to support
replication of BLOB/TEXT (also with ENGINE=ndb)
- change the suppression since the warning printed to error log
now says "Column 1"
The slave was not able to find the correct row in the innodb
table, because the row fetched from the innodb table would not
match the before image. This happened because the (don't care)
bytes in the NULLed fields would change once the row was stored
in the storage engine (from zero to the default value). This
would make bulk memory comparison (using memcmp) to fail.
We fix this by taking a preventing measure and avoiding memcmp
for tables that contain nullable fields. Therefore, we protect
the slave search routine from engines that return arbitrary
values for don't care bytes (in the nulled fields). Instead, the
slave thread will only check null_bits and those fields that are
not set to NULL when comparing the before image against the
storage engine row.
Currently, rpl_semi_sync is failing in PB due to the warning message:
"Slave SQL: slave SQL thread is being stopped in the middle of "
"applying of a group having updated a non-transaction table; "
"waiting for the group completion ..."
The problem started happening after the fix for BUG#11762407 what was
automatically suppressing some warning messages.
To fix the current issue, we suppress the aforementioned warning message
and exploit the opportunity to make the sentence clearer.
FAILED DROP DATABASE CAN BREAK STATEMENT BASED REPLICATION
The first phase of DROP DATABASE is to delete the tables in the database.
If deletion of one or more of the tables fail (e.g. due to a FOREIGN KEY
constraint), DROP DATABASE will be aborted. However, some tables could
still have been deleted. The problem was that nothing would be written
to the binary log in this case, so any slaves would not delete these tables.
Therefore the master and the slaves would get out of sync.
This patch fixes the problem by making sure that DROP TABLE is written
to the binary log for the tables that were in fact deleted by the failed
DROP DATABASE statement.
Test case added to binlog.binlog_database.test.
In SBR, if a statement does not fail, it is always written to the binary
log, regardless if rows are changed or not. If there is a failure, a
statement is only written to the binary log if a non-transactional (.e.g.
MyIsam) engine is updated.
INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE and INSERT IGNORE were not following the
rule above and were not written to the binary log, if then engine was
Innodb.
The test started failing on the same day patch for BUG 49978 was
pushed. BUG 49978 changed part of the replication testing
infrastructure in mysql-test-run. This caused the test to fail
sporadically with result differences on relay log file
names. When the test fails the relay-log filenames are shifted by
one, eg:
-show relaylog events in 'slave-relay-bin.000002' from <binlog_start>;
+show relaylog events in 'slave-relay-bin.000003' from <binlog_start>;
The problem was caused by a bad cleanup when using the include
files:
- include/setup_fake_relay_log.inc
- include/cleanup_fake_relay_log.inc
Which would leave a spurious relay-log file around (not listed in
slave-relay-bin.index), causing the server to shift the name of
the relay logs by one, even if cleaning up with RESET SLAVE.
We fix this by removing the relay-log file when it is not needed
anymore, ie at setup time and after recreating the fake relay-log
index.
Additionally, to make the affected test more resilient, we
deployed a call to rpl_reset.inc (which resets both master and
slave, including log files) before actually running the test
case.
Finally, appart from the reported bug, we also fix: (a) an
unrelated issue with the failing test itself - in some cases, the
test was not setting the log file name to use when it should;
(b) one typo.
Normally, auto_increment value is generated for the column by
inserting either NULL or 0 into it. NO_AUTO_VALUE_ON_ZERO
suppresses this behavior for 0 so that only NULL generates
the auto_increment value. This behavior is also followed by
a slave, specifically by the SQL Thread, when applying events
in the statement format from a master. However, when applying
events in the row format, the flag was ignored thus causing
an assertion failure:
"Assertion failed: next_insert_id == 0, file .\handler.cc"
In fact, we never need to generate a auto_increment value for
the column when applying events in row format on slave. So we
don't allow it to happen by using 'MODE_NO_AUTO_VALUE_ON_ZERO'.
Refactoring: Get rid of all the sql_mode checks to rows_log_event
when applying it for avoiding problems caused by the inconsistency
of the sql_mode on slave and master as the sql_mode is not set for
Rows_log_event.
Normally, auto_increment value is generated for the column by
inserting either NULL or 0 into it. NO_AUTO_VALUE_ON_ZERO
suppresses this behavior for 0 so that only NULL generates
the auto_increment value. This behavior is also followed by
a slave, specifically by the SQL Thread, when applying events
in the statement format from a master. However, when applying
events in the row format, the flag was ignored thus causing
an assertion failure:
"Assertion failed: next_insert_id == 0, file .\handler.cc"
In fact, we never need to generate a auto_increment value for
the column when applying events in row format on slave. So we
don't allow it to happen by using 'MODE_NO_AUTO_VALUE_ON_ZERO'.
Refactoring: Get rid of all the sql_mode checks to rows_log_event
when applying it for avoiding problems caused by the inconsistency
of the sql_mode on slave and master as the sql_mode is not set for
Rows_log_event.
Major replication test framework cleanup. This does the following:
- Ensure that all tests clean up the replication state when they
finish, by making check-testcase check the output of SHOW SLAVE STATUS.
This implies:
- Slave must not be running after test finished. This is good
because it removes the risk for sporadic errors in subsequent
tests when a test forgets to sync correctly.
- Slave SQL and IO errors must be cleared when test ends. This is
good because we will notice if a test gets an unexpected error in
the slave threads near the end.
- We no longer have to clean up before a test starts.
- Ensure that all tests that wait for an error in one of the slave
threads waits for a specific error. It is no longer possible to
source wait_for_slave_[sql|io]_to_stop.inc when there is an error
in one of the slave threads. This is good because:
- If a test expects an error but there is a bug that causes
another error to happen, or if it stops the slave thread without
an error, then we will notice.
- When developing tests, wait_for_*_to_[start|stop].inc will fail
immediately if there is an error in the relevant slave thread.
Before this patch, we had to wait for the timeout.
- Remove duplicated and repeated code for setting up unusual replication
topologies. Now, there is a single file that is capable of setting
up arbitrary topologies (include/rpl_init.inc, but
include/master-slave.inc is still available for the most common
topology). Tests can now end with include/rpl_end.inc, which will clean
up correctly no matter what topology is used. The topology can be
changed with include/rpl_change_topology.inc.
- Improved debug information when tests fail. This includes:
- debug info is printed on all servers configured by include/rpl_init.inc
- User can set $rpl_debug=1, which makes auxiliary replication files
print relevant debug info.
- Improved documentation for all auxiliary replication files. Now they
describe purpose, usage, parameters, and side effects.
- Many small code cleanups:
- Made have_innodb.inc output a sensible error message.
- Moved contents of rpl000017-slave.sh into rpl000017.test
- Added mysqltest variables that expose the current state of
disable_warnings/enable_warnings and friends.
- Too many to list here: see per-file comments for details.
