The issue is that trx_t::lock.was_chosen_as_deadlock_victim can be reset
before the transaction check it and set trx_t::error_state.
The fix is to reset trx_t::lock.was_chosen_as_deadlock_victim only in
trx_t::commit_in_memory(), which is invoked on full rollback. There is
also no need to have separate bit in
trx_t::lock.was_chosen_as_deadlock_victim to flag transaction it was
chosen as a victim of Galera conflict resolution, the same variable can be
used for both cases except debug build. For debug build we need to
distinguish deadlock and Galera's abort victims for debug checks. Also
there is no need to check for deadlock in lock_table_enqueue_waiting() for
Galera as the coresponding check presents in lock_wait().
Local variable "error_state" in lock_wait() was replaced with
trx->error_state, because before the replace
lock_sys_t::cancel<false>(trx, lock) and lock_sys.deadlock_check() could
change trx->error_state, which then could be overwritten with the local
"error_state" variable value.
The lock_wait_suspend_thread_enter DEBUG_SYNC point name is misleading,
because lock_wait_suspend_thread was eliminated in e71e613. It was renamed
to lock_wait_start.
Reviewed by: Marko Mäkelä, Jan Lindström.
sel_restore_position_for_mysql() moves forward persistent cursor
position after btr_pcur_restore_position() call if cursor relative position
is BTR_PCUR_ON and the cursor points to the record with NOT the same field
values as in a stored record(and some other not important for this case
conditions).
It was done because btr_pcur_restore_position() sets
page_cur_mode_t mode to PAGE_CUR_LE for cursor->rel_pos == BTR_PCUR_ON
before opening cursor. So we are searching for the record less or equal
to stored one. And if the found record is not equal to stored one, then
it is less and we need to move cursor forward.
But there can be a situation when the stored record was purged, but the
new one with the same key but different value was inserted while
row_search_mvcc() was suspended. In this case, when the thread is
awaken, it will invoke sel_restore_position_for_mysql(), which, in turns,
invoke btr_pcur_restore_position(), which will return false because found
record don't match stored record, and
sel_restore_position_for_mysql() will move forward cursor position.
The above can lead to the case when awaken row_search_mvcc() do not see
records inserted by other transactions while it slept. The mtr test case
shows the example how it can be.
The fix is to return special value from persistent cursor restoring
function which would notify its caller that uniq fields of restored
record and stored record are the same, and in this case
sel_restore_position_for_mysql() don't move cursor forward.
Delete-marked records are correctly processed in row_search_mvcc().
Non-unique secondary indexes are "uniquified" by adding the PK, the
index->n_uniq should then be index->n_fields. So there is no need in
additional checks in the fix.
If transaction's readview can't see the changes made in secondary index
record, it requests clustered index record in row_search_mvcc() to check
its transaction id and get the correspondent record version. After this
row_search_mvcc() commits mtr to preserve clustered index latching
order, and starts mtr. Between those mtr commit and start secondary
index pages are unlatched, and purge has the ability to remove stored in
the cursor record, what causes rows duplication in result set for
non-locking reads, as cursor position is restored to the previously
visited record.
To solve this the changes are just switched off for non-locking reads,
it's quite simple solution, besides the changes don't make sense for
non-locking reads.
The more complex and effective from performance perspective solution is
to create mtr savepoint before clustered record requesting and rolling
back to that savepoint after that. See MDEV-27557.
One more solution is to have per-record transaction id for secondary
indexes. See MDEV-17598.
If any of those is implemented, just remove select_lock_type argument in
sel_restore_position_for_mysql().
