1
0
mirror of https://github.com/MariaDB/server.git synced 2025-08-01 03:47:19 +03:00

A fix and a test case for Bug#26141 mixing table types in trigger

causes full table lock on innodb table.
Also fixes Bug#28502 Triggers that update another innodb table 
will block on X lock unnecessarily (duplciate).
Code review fixes.

Both bugs' synopses are misleading: InnoDB table is
not X locked. The statements, however, cannot proceed concurrently, 
but this happens due to lock conflicts for tables used in triggers,
not for the InnoDB table. 

If a user had an InnoDB table, and two triggers, AFTER UPDATE and 
AFTER INSERT, competing for different resources (e.g. two distinct
MyISAM tables), then these two triggers would not be able to execute
concurrently. Moreover, INSERTS/UPDATES of the InnoDB table would
not be able to run concurrently. 
The problem had other side-effects (see respective bug reports).

This behavior was a consequence of a shortcoming of the pre-locking
algorithm, which would not distinguish between different DML operations
(e.g. INSERT and DELETE) and pre-lock all the tables
that are used by any trigger defined on the subject table.

The idea of the fix is to extend the pre-locking algorithm to keep track,
for each table, what DML operation it is used for and not
load triggers that are known to never be fired.
This commit is contained in:
kostja@bodhi.(none)
2007-07-12 22:26:41 +04:00
parent 392b283f3d
commit 5ab4b6f1ac
18 changed files with 1255 additions and 58 deletions

View File

@ -1476,4 +1476,461 @@ DROP TRIGGER t1_test;
DROP TABLE t1,t2;
SET SESSION LOW_PRIORITY_UPDATES=DEFAULT;
SET GLOBAL LOW_PRIORITY_UPDATES=DEFAULT;
Bug#28502 Triggers that update another innodb table will block
on X lock unnecessarily
Ensure we do not open and lock tables for triggers we do not fire.
drop table if exists t1, t2;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_au;
create table t1 (id int, count int);
create table t2 (id int);
create trigger trg_bug28502_au before update on t2
for each row
begin
if (new.id is not null) then
update t1 set count= count + 1 where id = old.id;
end if;
end|
insert into t1 (id, count) values (1, 0);
lock table t1 write;
insert into t2 set id=1;
unlock tables;
update t2 set id=1 where id=1;
select * from t1;
id count
1 1
select * from t2;
id
1
drop table t1, t2;
Additionally, provide test coverage for triggers and
all MySQL data changing commands.
drop table if exists t1, t2, t1_op_log;
drop view if exists v1;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_bi;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_ai;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_bu;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_au;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_bd;
drop trigger if exists trg_bug28502_ad;
create table t1 (id int primary key auto_increment, operation varchar(255));
create table t2 (id int primary key);
create table t1_op_log(operation varchar(255));
create view v1 as select * from t1;
create trigger trg_bug28502_bi before insert on t1
for each row
insert into t1_op_log (operation)
values (concat("Before INSERT, new=", new.operation));
create trigger trg_bug28502_ai after insert on t1
for each row
insert into t1_op_log (operation)
values (concat("After INSERT, new=", new.operation));
create trigger trg_bug28502_bu before update on t1
for each row
insert into t1_op_log (operation)
values (concat("Before UPDATE, new=", new.operation,
", old=", old.operation));
create trigger trg_bug28502_au after update on t1
for each row
insert into t1_op_log (operation)
values (concat("After UPDATE, new=", new.operation,
", old=", old.operation));
create trigger trg_bug28502_bd before delete on t1
for each row
insert into t1_op_log (operation)
values (concat("Before DELETE, old=", old.operation));
create trigger trg_bug28502_ad after delete on t1
for each row
insert into t1_op_log (operation)
values (concat("After DELETE, old=", old.operation));
insert into t1 (operation) values ("INSERT");
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 INSERT
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT
After INSERT, new=INSERT
truncate t1_op_log;
update t1 set operation="UPDATE" where id=@id;
select * from t1;
id operation
1 UPDATE
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before UPDATE, new=UPDATE, old=INSERT
After UPDATE, new=UPDATE, old=INSERT
truncate t1_op_log;
delete from t1 where id=@id;
select * from t1;
id operation
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before DELETE, old=UPDATE
After DELETE, old=UPDATE
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into t1 (id, operation) values
(NULL, "INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key")
on duplicate key update id=NULL, operation="Should never happen";
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into t1 (id, operation) values
(@id, "INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, the key value is the same")
on duplicate key update id=NULL,
operation="INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate";
select * from t1;
id operation
0 INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, the key value is the same
Before UPDATE, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate, old=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
After UPDATE, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate, old=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into t1 values (NULL, "REPLACE, inserting a new key");
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into t1 values (@id, "REPLACE, deleting the duplicate");
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE, deleting the duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE, deleting the duplicate
Before DELETE, old=REPLACE, inserting a new key
After DELETE, old=REPLACE, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE, deleting the duplicate
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
create table if not exists t1
select NULL, "CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key";
Warnings:
Note 1050 Table 't1' already exists
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
create table if not exists t1 replace
select @id, "CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key";
Warnings:
Note 1050 Table 't1' already exists
select * from t1;
id operation
1 CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key
Before DELETE, old=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After DELETE, old=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into t1 (id, operation)
select NULL, "INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key";
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into t1 (id, operation)
select @id,
"INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate"
on duplicate key update id=NULL,
operation="INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate";
select * from t1;
id operation
0 INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate
Before UPDATE, new=INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate, old=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After UPDATE, new=INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate, old=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into t1 (id, operation)
select NULL, "REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key";
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into t1 (id, operation)
select @id, "REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate";
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate
Before DELETE, old=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After DELETE, old=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into t1 (id, operation) values (1, "INSERT for multi-DELETE");
insert into t2 (id) values (1);
delete t1.*, t2.* from t1, t2 where t1.id=1;
select * from t1;
id operation
select * from t2;
id
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-DELETE
After INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-DELETE
Before DELETE, old=INSERT for multi-DELETE
After DELETE, old=INSERT for multi-DELETE
truncate t1;
truncate t2;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into t1 (id, operation) values (1, "INSERT for multi-UPDATE");
insert into t2 (id) values (1);
update t1, t2 set t1.id=2, operation="multi-UPDATE" where t1.id=1;
update t1, t2
set t2.id=3, operation="multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired" where t1.id=2;
select * from t1;
id operation
2 multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired
select * from t2;
id
3
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
After INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
Before UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, old=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
After UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, old=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
Before UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired, old=multi-UPDATE
After UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired, old=multi-UPDATE
truncate table t1;
truncate table t2;
truncate table t1_op_log;
Now do the same but use a view instead of the base table.
insert into v1 (operation) values ("INSERT");
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 INSERT
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT
After INSERT, new=INSERT
truncate t1_op_log;
update v1 set operation="UPDATE" where id=@id;
select * from t1;
id operation
1 UPDATE
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before UPDATE, new=UPDATE, old=INSERT
After UPDATE, new=UPDATE, old=INSERT
truncate t1_op_log;
delete from v1 where id=@id;
select * from t1;
id operation
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before DELETE, old=UPDATE
After DELETE, old=UPDATE
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into v1 (id, operation) values
(NULL, "INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key")
on duplicate key update id=NULL, operation="Should never happen";
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into v1 (id, operation) values
(@id, "INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, the key value is the same")
on duplicate key update id=NULL,
operation="INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate";
select * from t1;
id operation
0 INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, the key value is the same
Before UPDATE, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate, old=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
After UPDATE, new=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating the duplicate, old=INSERT ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, inserting a new key
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into v1 values (NULL, "REPLACE, inserting a new key");
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into v1 values (@id, "REPLACE, deleting the duplicate");
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE, deleting the duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE, deleting the duplicate
Before DELETE, old=REPLACE, inserting a new key
After DELETE, old=REPLACE, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE, deleting the duplicate
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
create table if not exists v1
select NULL, "CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key";
Warnings:
Note 1050 Table 'v1' already exists
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
create table if not exists v1 replace
select @id, "CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key";
Warnings:
Note 1050 Table 'v1' already exists
select * from t1;
id operation
1 CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key
Before DELETE, old=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After DELETE, old=CREATE TABLE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=CREATE TABLE ... REPLACE SELECT, deleting a duplicate key
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into v1 (id, operation)
select NULL, "INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key";
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into v1 (id, operation)
select @id,
"INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate"
on duplicate key update id=NULL,
operation="INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate";
select * from t1;
id operation
0 INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate
Before UPDATE, new=INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate, old=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After UPDATE, new=INSERT ... SELECT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE, updating a duplicate, old=INSERT ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into v1 (id, operation)
select NULL, "REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key";
set @id=last_insert_id();
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
truncate t1_op_log;
replace into v1 (id, operation)
select @id, "REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate";
select * from t1;
id operation
1 REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate
Before DELETE, old=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After DELETE, old=REPLACE ... SELECT, inserting a new key
After INSERT, new=REPLACE ... SELECT, deleting a duplicate
truncate t1;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into v1 (id, operation) values (1, "INSERT for multi-DELETE");
insert into t2 (id) values (1);
delete v1.*, t2.* from v1, t2 where v1.id=1;
select * from t1;
id operation
select * from t2;
id
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-DELETE
After INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-DELETE
Before DELETE, old=INSERT for multi-DELETE
After DELETE, old=INSERT for multi-DELETE
truncate t1;
truncate t2;
truncate t1_op_log;
insert into v1 (id, operation) values (1, "INSERT for multi-UPDATE");
insert into t2 (id) values (1);
update v1, t2 set v1.id=2, operation="multi-UPDATE" where v1.id=1;
update v1, t2
set t2.id=3, operation="multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired" where v1.id=2;
select * from t1;
id operation
2 multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired
select * from t2;
id
3
select * from t1_op_log;
operation
Before INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
After INSERT, new=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
Before UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, old=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
After UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, old=INSERT for multi-UPDATE
Before UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired, old=multi-UPDATE
After UPDATE, new=multi-UPDATE, SET for t2, but the trigger is fired, old=multi-UPDATE
drop view v1;
drop table t1, t2, t1_op_log;
End of 5.0 tests